Beware
of the Dimond Brothers
It has been quite some time since I’ve added anything new to
the Admonishments subsection of The Epistemologic Works, and, honestly, I have
avoided additional admonishments because I dread them. That is to say, it is
not ‘fun’ for me to do this. I derive no satisfaction from it. I
don’t ‘hate’ persons that I feel convicted to admonish, and
one must be exceedingly careful in doing so publicly. To top it off, I’ve
never pretended to have ecclesial ‘authority’ or
‘jurisdiction’ over such people. Why, then, do I do so?
Because this is the Great Apostasy, with no functioning Hierarchy
as Our Creator punishes a wicked world and people who were supposed to be
Catholic, putting His Divine Son’s Church Body ‘in the tomb’,
so to speak, just as this Eternally Divine Son, Jesus Christ, was Himself in
the Tomb after His Crucifixion upon the Cross. Hence, we cannot depend on licit
shepherds --- Roman Catholic Clergy --- to deal with these matters in the
meantime. And, since God has permitted me thus far, however small &
unknown, to publicly uphold Roman Catholicism Whole & Entire in a way that
practically anyone in the world may see & read, then, too, I have an
occasional responsibility to warn my fellow Catholics of people dangerously
heretical, schismatic, apostate, or otherwise openly & seriously sinful. Difficult territory? Indeed. I take no pleasure in it.
It is further complicated in the matter of the Dimond brothers. How
so?
I’ve never met them personally. I also thought & prayed
long and hard about how to admonish them properly. Up till now, what few souls
I have felt compelled to admonish, I have been able to both contact personally
and, much of the time, had known personally. This is not the case with the
Dimond brothers. Yet I have known people who have been associated with them
personally, I have examined their website quite a few times, and their tactics
are very familiar to me. They are Catholic
fundamentalists. Please follow the link just given if you
don’t know what CFs are
or their characteristics.
I once admonished someone from afar, having never personally met
him.
The catch is, is it my individual
responsibility to do so in every case with a person I’ve never met or
known in person? And the answer is, no, not necessarily. If they are public in
some sense, claiming to defend, explain or uphold some aspect of the Catholic
Faith, then, as people who have chosen to do so, a Roman Catholic can
justifiably admonish ‘remotely’ at a distance, as it were. This is
what I’m doing here regarding the Dimonds. It’s plain from many
years of observation how they would respond (read:
badly, with a spleen & venom that is pretty vicious). Nor has Heaven
given me any sense that I must attempt to do so, in spite of such probable
viciousness. I therefore simply warn you.
As far as I can tell, the Dimond brothers and their
‘monastery’ have gotten a lot of things right about the Catholic
Religion and the current state of the world we’re in. I would not
unfairly accuse them of being totally wrong. Nonetheless, they are definitely
mistaken about a few things, and these few are definitely deadly to a
person’s soul. But first:
Who are the Dimond brothers? They hail from the northeastern
I wish to be fair, however. The Dimond brothers
website, videos, literature & whatnot is huge, more material than I have
the time to fully read, watch & digest. Much of what they say is true &
good, perhaps the majority of it. I don’t claim to know for sure. Yet I
cannot spend enormous time doing so because the things they get wrong are grave.
Being CFs, zealously studying their materials will ultimately do one of two
things. Either, one, the reader will wind up believing & following them in
the matters they get terribly wrong, becoming CFs just like them. Or else, two,
you will eventually be scathed by them or their followers, having the audacity
to courteously disagree with or debate them.
Whichever the case, much harm is done to the person imbibing their
materials.
And where do they go gravely wrong? What are their terrible
mistakes?
Without pretending to be aware of every major mistake they may
make, I can, with certainty, speak of four problems that are more than enough
to cause the real & wise Catholic to be wary of them. (By the way, if the one reading this admonishment can demonstrate to me
that I’m mistaken about their mistakes, or that they’ve changed
their positions for the better, please politely inform me. I don’t want
to slander anyone, neither do I wish to unjustly
detract in regard to anyone’s reputation, howsoever public they be.)
Shall we examine each of them briefly, one by one, my precious & beloved
reader?
First, they go CF
(Catholic fundamentalist) over the issue of water baptism. You may peruse this
topic comprehensively at The Epistemologic Works in
Baptismal Confusion
. In short, there is an orthodox --- thus far
--- opinion concerning the Sacrament of Baptism called ‘baptism of
desire’ (BOD). This theological opinion, which has swayed a majority of
Catholics since the mid-2nd millennium until the Great Apostasy just
recently, is that catechumens (those
studying to be true Catholics) who die ‘accidentally’ prior to
water baptism, may, with perfect contrition, enter Heaven since God very
charitably grants exceptions in such cases. This BOD stance, taught scholastic
theologians, somehow mysteriously connects to the Sacrament of Baptism via the
catechumen’s ‘desire’ or resolution, religiously, to receive
the sacramental water. Thus, it is not,
understood rightly, another
baptism, but another way to
partake in one Sacrament of
Baptism. Whereas the opinion of ‘water only’ (WO) says catechumens,
dying void of water baptism, are ‘surely’ in hell. Per the WO
stance, God never permits a
good-willed catechumen to die without
the sacramental water bestowed on him or her. Upshot?
Strangely enough, both sides use the Council of Trent to defend their position.
Now, obviously, an infallible council cannot
teach two opposing views simultaneously. In reality,
Second, the Dimond
brothers and their followers go CF over the issue of the Coredemptress. For
many centuries, the Catholic Church has not only tolerated this wonderful title
for the Blessed Virgin Mary, but has even encouraged it. Per them and their
followers, this is making God’s Mother ‘equal’ to Her Son,
Jesus Christ, they then accusing you of ‘heresy’ for daring to
honor Her with this title. It does not matter how hard you try to explain to
such people that calling Queen Mary the Coredemptress, or Comediatrix, or etc.,
etc., is not intended to say
--- nor does it ‘have
to mean’ --- that Mary is ‘equal’ to Her Divine Son. It matters
not to them or their followers. They will savage a real Catholic for using the
terms or defending the terms. Again, as far as I can tell, the Dimonds are the
origin of this weird notion. Yet the weirdness is not the crucial point. The
fact that they can influence real Catholics to go damnably schismatic about
this subject is the crux. It is mortally
sinful. And thus why
it is gravely mistaken.
Readers, by the way, may go
here to see that these titles are utterly
orthodox.
Third, the Dimonds
&
Leading us to a fourth
problem displayed by the Dimond brothers or their adherents. Simply put, they
do not understand when & how a real Catholic is to admonish others. That is
to say, even when they’re correct about something religious --- for
instance, they appear to uphold ‘no Salvation outside the Church’
accurately --- notwithstanding, they admonish when it’s not truly necessary to admonish
a person, and, though it might be time to admonish someone, they are needlessly
cruel in doing so. This,
also, can lead Roman Catholics into mortal
sin. And therefore why,
again, it is gravely mistaken.
Incidentally, I do not claim to be ‘perfect’ in this matter. I do,
though, insist there is prudent protocol in admonishing others, regardless of
any faults I may bear. At any rate… please go
here
to see what not to do
in admonishing. It might help to study carefully
here, and
here as well, for
yet more guidance about admonishments.
Hopefully, this is enough to see why a real Catholic, or someone becoming truly Catholic, should be wary of the Dimond brothers, their monastery, or their followers. Please pray for them. At the very least, they are schismatic and hence not Catholic. An actual Roman Catholic should ask King Jesus & Queen Mary to grant them the graces to perceive their grave mistakes, repudiate them, and to be really Roman Catholic Whole, Entire & Undefiled --- and to be the best possible Catholics they could ever be.
+
+ +
Pilate’s
query met:
Note:
if you’ve come
to this webpage directly from a search
engine or other
website, then, when done viewing this webpage
--- and assuming
you wish to view more of this website’s pages ---
please type the
website’s address (as given above right before this
note) into the
address bar at the top of your browser and hit the
‘enter’ button on the keyboard of your computer.
Please go here about use of the writings
on this website.
© 2019 by
Paul Doughton.
All rights
reserved.